top of page

Allie Beth Stuckey and Raymond Ibrahim Explore America’s Barbary Wars and Legacy of Conflict


Top Points

  • America’s First Foreign War: The U.S. fought the Barbary Pirates to defend its sovereignty and build its naval strength.

  • Lasting Cultural Tensions: The conflict revealed early ideological divides between the West and Islamic powers.

  • Strength Over Appeasement: The lesson remains that peace is earned through strength and moral resolve.


Full Report:

On a recent episode of Relatable, host Allie Beth Stuckey welcomed Raymond Ibrahim, historian and expert in Islamic-Western relations, to discuss how the young United States confronted the Barbary corsairs of North Africa and how that early conflict still echoes in today’s Middle East tensions. The conversation covered naval battles, diplomacy, and the cultural history of America’s first foreign war.


America’s First Foreign Conflict and the Barbary Threat

Stuckey began the episode by asking Ibrahim why Americans rarely hear about the Barbary Wars when discussing U.S. foreign policy and Islamic conflict. Ibrahim explained that the Barbary States, including Tripoli, Algiers, and Tunis, had for centuries launched pirate raids on European and American merchant ships, enslaved their crews, and demanded tribute. He noted that in 1785, two American ships, the Maria and the Dauphin, were captured by the Barbary pirates, drawing the United States into its first overseas crisis.


He said the conflict showed how the young American republic would not pay tribute or bow to foreign demands but would instead fight for its rights at sea and its national dignity. The raids by the pirates and later battles, such as at Derna, became foundational to the U.S. Navy’s identity and inspired the phrase “to the shores of Tripoli” in the Marine Corps Hymn.


The Historical Link to Islamic and Middle East Tensions

The discussion then turned to how Ibrahim sees a continuous thread from the Barbary era to modern-day tensions between the West and the Islamic world. He argued that the ideological motives of the Barbary corsairs reflected a worldview in which raiding and warfare against non-Muslims were seen as legitimate under certain interpretations of Islamic law.


Stuckey and Ibrahim discussed how early treaties, such as the Treaty of Tripoli, attempted to formalize peace but also revealed cultural misunderstandings between the United States and Muslim rulers of the time. Ibrahim explained that recognizing these early conflicts helps Americans understand that tension between Western and Islamic civilizations is not new but part of a long historical pattern.


Why This Matters Today

For listeners of Relatable, the episode offered an important reminder that America’s engagement with the Islamic world began long before modern terrorism or oil politics. Stuckey asked Ibrahim what lessons today’s policymakers and citizens should draw from the Barbary experience. He responded that peace built on appeasement rarely lasts and that liberty and security require strength and moral clarity.


Ibrahim emphasized that the same lessons apply today when the United States faces threats from radical ideologies or unstable regimes. He said that remembering the Barbary Wars reminds Americans that defending national sovereignty and freedom has always required resolve and unity.


Conclusion

In this episode of Relatable, Allie Beth Stuckey and Raymond Ibrahim explored how the Barbary Wars shaped America’s early identity and revealed enduring cultural and political challenges between the West and the Islamic world. Their discussion connected history to the present, reminding listeners that the defense of freedom and national integrity is a duty that transcends centuries.


References

bottom of page